The Supreme Court Partially Allowed Trump’s Travel Ban. Who Is Still Barred? By ALICIA PARLAPIANO and ANJALI SINGHVI

Portions of President Trump’s travel ban went into effect at the end of June, after the Supreme Court temporarily lifted legal blocks on the ban and agreed to review the case this fall.
The court granted an exception for people with “bona fide relationships” in the United States. Last week, a federal judge in Hawaii challenged the Trump administration’s definition of the term, opening the gates for grandparents and other close relatives, as well as thousands of refugees who have been cleared to enter the United States.
On Wednesday, the Supreme Court weighed in again, rejecting part of the Hawaii judge’s order and allowing the administration to temporarily enforce its restrictions on refugees.
ALLOWED
People With ‘Bona Fide’ Relationships in the U.S.
In June, the Supreme Court lifted the suspensions that federal judges had put on Mr. Trump’s travel ban order in March, but only partially: People from the affected countries who have “a credible claim of a bona fide relationship with a person or entity in the United States” will still be allowed to enter the country.
The justices said their intention was to not burden American parties who have relationships with foreigners. They offered some examples of who would be allowed, including “close family,” students and workers offered employment.
But the court did not precisely explain the meaning of “bona fide relationship.” According to a diplomatic cable obtained by The New York Times, the Trump administration has defined “close family” as a “parent (including parent-in-law), spouse, child, adult son or daughter, son-in-law, daughter-in-law, sibling, whether whole or half. This includes step relationships.” The administration later added people who are engaged to be married to the list of sufficient connections.
But the federal judge in Hawaii said that the administration could not exclude other extended family members, including “grandparents, grandchildren, brothers-in-law, sisters-in-law, aunts, uncles, nieces, nephews and cousins.” On Wednesday, the Supreme Court temporarily let that portion of the Hawaii court order stand.
BARRED
Everyone Else From Six Countries

The president’s order prohibits for 90 days the entry of travelers from six predominantly Muslim countries: Iran, Libya, Somalia, Sudan, Syria and Yemen. The Supreme Court’s action in June means that this ban will only apply to those without bona fide relationships in the United States.
Meanwhile, American officials will conduct a review into screening procedures in place to prevent threats. Travelers from countries that do not provide sufficient information for screening by the end of the review may still be barred from entering the United States.
In its opinion, the court said the administration could complete its review over the summer, so it is possible that the case could become moot by the time it is argued in the fall.
DEPENDS
Refugees
The president’s order also includes a ban on all refugees to the United States for 120 days. After that, the administration will determine from which countries it will reinstate admissions.
Mr. Trump’s order allows case-by-case exceptions for some refugees, and refugees already admitted to the country will be allowed. The court’s exception for those with a bona fide relationship also applies to refugees, but according to independent estimates, about 40 percent of refugees who come to the country have no family ties here.
A State Department official originally said that refugees’ ties to a nonprofit organization that helped them resettle was “not sufficient” to qualify as a bona fide relationship. The federal judge in Hawaii ruled that the administration could not exclude refugees with ties to a resettlement agency that was committed to receiving them, but the Supreme Court on Wednesday temporarily blocked that part of the ruling.
The president’s order cuts the refugee program in half, capping it at 50,000 people for the 2017 fiscal year, down from the 110,000 ceiling put in place under President Barack Obama. But the cap will not apply to refugees who can claim a bona fide relationship.
ALLOWED
Students and Workers Without Current Visas
Mr. Trump’s order applies to people who do not have current visas, including temporary, non-immigrant visas for students and workers. But these groups already get those visas based on relationships the administration has defined as bona fide, so they will be allowed in.
There were about 13,000 temporary visits by citizens from the six targeted countries in the 2015 fiscal year in those categories.
DEPENDS
Tourists and business travelers
Like students and workers, most visitors coming to the United States for recreational and business purposes must obtain non-immigrant visas. Those from the six countries will be allowed only if they already have a qualifying bona fide relationship in the United States.
That includes “close family” or a relationship with a “U.S. entity”; for example, the administration said that a “lecturer invited to address an audience” would qualify.
There were 49,412 visits by citizens from the six targeted countries on the B-1 and B-2 visas in 2015.
DEPENDS
New Immigrants
Mr. Trump’s order also applies to people from the six countries newly arriving on immigrant visas. But most of these visas are granted based on employment or family status that would qualify them to enter under the court’s opinion.
A small percentage of new immigrants are awarded “diversity visas” through a lottery, so it is possible that they would not have bona fide relationships that would allow them to enter.
People issued immigrant visas become legal permanent residents on arrival in the United States and are issued a green card soon after. In 2015, green cards were issued to 31,258 people from these six countries. In general, about half of recent new legal permanent residents have been new arrivals to the country, and the other half have had their status adjusted after living in the United States.
ALLOWED
Green Card Holders, Dual Nationals and Diplomats
Mr. Trump’s order explicitly says green card holders from the targeted countries will be allowed. From 1999 to 2015, 2.6 percent of new legal permanent residents were from the six affected countries.
The president’s order also does not apply to American citizens, or to dual nationals who enter the United States presenting their passport from a country not under the ban.
People on certain types of diplomatic or government visas are also still allowed. Nearly 1,400 admissions from the six countries were made on these visas in 2015:
Diplomats and other officials
Diplomats and officials (and their families) on A-1 and A-2 visas
International representatives
Representatives of foreign governments or international organizations holding G-1, G-2, G-3 or G-4 visas
Visitors to the United Nations
People with C-2 visas to travel to the United Nations or officials in transit with C-3 visas
NATO officials
Officials (and their families) on North Atlantic Treaty Organization visas
How the Ban Has Evolved
After a panel of federal judges blocked key parts of a January order banning travel from seven predominantly Muslim countries, Mr. Trump issued a narrower revised version in March, which, among other changes, removed Iraq from the list of barred countries and took out language prioritizing refugees in minority religious groups.
Federal judges blocked the new order in mid-March, and it had been on hold until the end of June, when the Supreme Court agreed to hear the case and allowed portions of it to go back into effect.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s