The Details of a UK Attorney General by Lawson Akhigbe

AG Richard Hermer

The Attorney General is one of those elegant British constitutional fictions that works beautifully on paper and rather less so when real power, real politics and real consequences collide.

In theory, the role is straightforward. The Attorney General is the chief legal adviser to the government, the guardian of the public interest in the courts, and the person who is supposed to stand slightly apart from the partisan scrum while still sitting firmly inside it. They superintend the Crown Prosecution Service and the Serious Fraud Office, decide whether certain sensitive prosecutions can proceed, and occasionally appear in court to argue points of high constitutional moment. They are both politician and lawyer, Cabinet member and independent officer of the law. The arrangement relies on a delicate balancing act: political loyalty without political capture, legal independence without constitutional naivety.

In practice, the role is a permanent tightrope walk over a pit of institutional self-interest.

The Attorney General is appointed by the Prime Minister, serves at the Prime Minister’s pleasure, and is expected to offer fearless legal advice to the very government that can end their career with a single phone call. This is not a design flaw. It is the design. The office is meant to internalise the tension between political necessity and legal propriety rather than resolve it. When the advice is convenient, it is celebrated as wise counsel. When it is inconvenient, it is quietly managed, rephrased, or, in more robust times, simply ignored while everyone maintains the polite fiction that the Attorney General remains independent.

History is littered with the results. The office has been used to authorise dubious military adventures, to withhold consent for prosecutions that would embarrass the state, and to defend the indefensible with the straight face that only a senior lawyer trained in the higher arts of institutional loyalty can manage. At the same time, it has occasionally produced genuine resistance: Attorneys General who refused to stretch the law past breaking point, who insisted that even governments must operate inside the legal framework they claim to uphold. Those moments are remembered precisely because they are exceptions.

The deeper problem is structural. A system that requires the government’s chief legal adviser to be both a political actor and an independent guardian of legality is asking one human being to serve two masters who are frequently at war. The public is then invited to believe that the tension is managed through personal integrity rather than institutional design. This is a comforting story. It is also an unreliable one.

When trust in the justice system is already strained as it was after the Birmingham Six, and as it remains whenever the state appears more interested in protecting its own reputation than in correcting its own errors the Attorney General becomes a particularly exposed figure. They are the living embodiment of the claim that power can police itself. Every time that claim looks threadbare, the office absorbs the damage.

None of this means the role is useless. A government without a senior lawyer who can still, on occasion, say “no” is a more dangerous government. But the myth of serene independence should be retired. The Attorney General is not a judicial figure in a wig who happens to attend Cabinet. They are a political appointee whose legal authority is permanently entangled with the government’s need for legitimacy. The tension is not a bug. It is the entire point of the job.

And like most elegant British constitutional arrangements, it works right up until the moment it is stress-tested by a government that prioritises outcomes over process. At which point the public discovers, once again, that the person charged with upholding the law is also the person charged with making the law look respectable while it is being bent.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.